Logo for Brothers Collision with an arrow and feather design, and text indicating it is the home of the Carlisle Indians.

Free Quotes

!

Free Quotes !

Welcome to Brother’s Collision

Where decades of local tradition meet a fresh, family-driven commitment to excellence. Proudly serving the Carlisle, OH community since 1987, we are excited to carry forward a legacy of quality auto body repair under the new ownership of the Shotwell brothers. Formerly known as Pearson Bros., our shop remains your trusted neighborhood destination for expert craftsmanship and honest service. Whether you’ve been with us for thirty years or are visiting for the first time, our family is dedicated to getting yours back on the road safely and with pride.

A New Chapter in a Carlisle Tradition

At Brother’s Collision, we believe that while names may change, quality craftsmanship and community trust should remain constant. For decades, Carlisle residents have relied on this shop for honest repairs and dependable service. When the Shotwell brothers took the helm, they didn’t just buy a business - they took on a responsibility to uphold the high standards established by the Pearson family. As a family-owned and operated shop, we understand that your vehicle isn’t just a machine; it’s what keeps your life moving, your family safe, and your daily routine on track.

“We look forward to providing the same quality collision repair that Pearson Bros has been providing for the last 38 years.” - The Shotwell Brothers

Why Choose Us?

We combine the “old school” values of integrity and hard work with modern repair techniques to ensure your vehicle is returned to its pre-accident condition.

  • Decades of Experience

    Built on a foundation of service that dates back to 1987.

  • Family-Owned Integrity

    The Shotwell brothers are personally involved in ensuring every job meets our high standards.

  • Community Focused

    We aren’t a giant corporate chain; we are your neighbors, committed to keeping Carlisle’s drivers safe.

  • Comprehensive Care

    From minor door dings to major collision restoration, we handle the heavy lifting so you don’t have to.

Our Commitment to You

Our mission is simple: to provide seamless, stress-free repairs that get you back on the road with confidence. We know that dealing with an accident is stressful enough, which is why we prioritize clear communication, fair pricing, and meticulous attention to detail.

 See What People Are Saying

Customer review for Tara, a Honda owner, dated January 13, 2026, expressing satisfaction with the helpful and kind people and recommending them to others.
Customer review by Damon, a Chevrolet owner, dated January 9, 2026, praising Pearson Brothers for excellent work on his truck's front end and sides, which looked better than new after repairs, highly recommending them for body repair.
Screenshot of a customer review from Barbara, Chevrolet owner, dated 12/31/25. The review includes five blue dots indicating a positive rating. Barbara's experience mentions that they appreciated being texted updates about their vehicle, bringing the
Customer review saying they had a positive experience with Pearson Brothers Body Shop for windshield-header rust repair on their Jeep, praising the shop's transparency, documentation, and professionalism.
A screenshot of a customer review showing the name Kenneth, a Ford owner, with the date 12/23/25. The review is titled "My Experience" and states, "They were very nice." The review is branded as a "Real Customer Review" with a blue circular icon with
Customer review with five blue dots, titled 'My Experience,' saying 'The best around!' by James, a Nissan owner, dated 12/16/25, with a gray footer labeled 'Real Customer Reviews' and a small circular logo in the bottom right corner.
Customer review from Jason, a Chevrolet owner, dated 12/13/25, praising the professionalism and responsiveness of Casey and Brittany, and expressing satisfaction with the work done on his truck, including buffing out marks on the bumper.
Customer review for Kimberly, a Jeep owner, dated 12/11/25, praising professional and friendly service, with five blue dots indicating a five-star rating.
A customer review for a Dodge repair shop, rated five stars, with positive comments about the repair quality, quick completion, and customer satisfaction, dated 12/8/25, with a green 'RECOMMENDS' badge.
Customer review message thanking a car team for their work, mentioning a Ford car, with the customer named Stuart, dated December 5, 2025.
Screenshot of a customer review for Pearson Brothers, dated December 5, 2025, from Jessie, a BMW owner. The review praises the professionalism, timely service, reasonable cost, cleanliness, and overall satisfaction with Pearson Brothers for car servi
Customer review showing 5-star rating for Madison's service, with positive feedback on recommendation likelihood, repair quality, customer service, communication, and timeliness.
Customer review from Brian, a GMC owner, dated 11/28/25, praising a friend's body work and paint service for making the vehicle look brand new.
Customer review with five blue dots, titled 'My Experience,' stating 'Very satisfied, thank you,' from Tom, a Chevrolet owner, dated 11/26/25.
Customer review screenshot with a five-star rating, name Ronald, dated 11/21/25, praising communication and happiness with repairs, signed as a Chevrolet owner.
Customer review showing five-star ratings for repair quality and customer service, with a recommendation rating. The review praises Pearson Brother's work and Brittany's communication, and is written by Marilee, a Lincoln owner as of November 12, 202
Customer review with five blue dots, titled 'My Experience,' praising Brit and Casey for excellent customer service and product quality, and recommending them.
Customer review for Pat, a Honda owner, praising the car detailing service for finishing earlier than expected, matching the quote, and making the car look great, with a willingness to recommend.
Customer review for Barb, Hyundai owner, dated 10/31/25, with a 5-star rating, praising excellent work and communication.
Screenshot of a review written by James, a Ford owner, dated 10/28/25. The review says "My Experience" and "Thank you." The bottom right corner has a blue and green logo with the text "Real Customer Reviews."
Screenshot of a customer review for Honda from October 22, 2025, thanking the staff for their helpful and professional service.
Customer review from Rhonda, a Chrysler owner, dated 10/21/25, praising the vehicle's condition and service, with a five-star rating, highlighted by blue dots, and a logo in the bottom right corner indicating real customer reviews.
Screenshot of a positive customer review for Ann, a Toyota owner, dated 10/8/25, stating 'My Experience Perfect. Thx. Will recommend you to others' with five blue dots and a customer review badge in the bottom right corner.
Customer review highlighting positive experience with Pearson Brothers, praising their quick and excellent service. The review is written by Rhonda, a Chevrolet owner, dated October 6, 2025.
Customer review screenshot with five blue dots, the text "My Experience," and the comment "Great job."
Customer review for Scott, a GMC owner, dated 9/29/25, expressing a positive experience with car repair, customer service, and staff friendliness.
Screenshot of a customer review for Doris, who owns Saturn, dated 9/27/25. The review titled "My Experience" praises how a lady’s fit over a Saturn was fixed to look cute and red, and the reviewer was happy to hear that.
Customer review for Darrell, a Kia owner, dated 9/19/25, praising the vehicle cleaning and work quality, with five blue dots indicating a five-star rating.
Screenshot of a customer review for Tommy, a RAM owner, dated 9/12/25, with five blue dots representing a five-star rating and the comment "My Experience."
Customer review with five blue dots, stating 'My Experience: Excellent job', dated 9/4/25, from Charles, a Chevrolet owner, part of a section called 'Real Customer Reviews'.